Skip to content

Careers Hub | What makes a good sales recruiter

Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    Over the years, I’ve seen my fair share of recruiters in action. I’ve seen the good, the bad, the ugly and everything in between, and am lucky to say that the team I have right now at Pulse Recruitment is the best that I’ve ever worked with. Quality training is crucial to developing a great recruiter, and on reflection, in the early days of my business, I made a lot of mistakes when it came to training and developing people in the business. The truth is, great recruiters have certain traits that are innate as well as those that can be developed, such as writing job ads. Quality, ongoing training is vital to success.

    I say what makes a good “Sales Recruiter” because this is specific to Pulse Recruitment, but these traits really apply to any recruiter, whether they are an agency or internal. Here are some of the more intangible traits that separate the good from the great and ones to look out for if you are a job seeker or looking to hire for your team;

     

    Inquisitive

    It’s a common belief that being naturally inquisitive is a trait of great salespeople, but the exact same applies to recruitment. You’ve got to be interested in your client’s business. Not just what they do but how they are different to their competition, what are their strengths and weaknesses and ultimately, what type of person will fit in with the team and respond to the company’s management style. Does this role have a short sales cycle or a longer one? Would the candidate need to be more strategic, detail-orientated person over a more transactional sales hunter with different skill sets? Being inquisitive means, you dig a little deeper and ask more questions which then gives you more information and knowledge towards painting a more rounded picture. The same inquisitive nature means that you will also want to learn more about candidates, from their key drivers to why they left certain roles, like putting a jigsaw together. You might be able to tell what the image is if you complete two-thirds of the jigsaw, but you only get full clarity once it’s complete. Being inquisitive also means that you gain trust, and that is at the heart of any relationship a recruiter has, and great recruiters work off trust and influence more than anything else.

     

    Dares to challenge

    The client isn’t always right! I am working with a small business owner right now to recruit a Business Development Manager. This owner is a highly creative person but freely admits that sales is not his strength and is therefore willing to take direction on everything from the commission structure on offer to their ideal target market. This is an example of where a recruiter can add real value to a business, but, in many other circumstances, it is very hard to say to a client, “the way you are hiring and doing things is wrong” when the client doesn’t really see an issue. This is where you have to be able to challenge your client and offer a better solution. Maybe the recruitment process is too long or good talent is being missed because there is too much focus on experience over soft skills. The bottom line is that you have to be able to challenge in certain circumstances and great recruiters back their judgement without being too pushy. They identify a weakness or an issue and are able to convey this effectively with the sole purpose of adding value. When it comes to candidates, the same is applied. People can have unrealistic expectations around salary, position and all manner of things, and it can be tough to challenge, but it can ultimately be a crucial piece of advice that ends up helping the individual for the rest of their career.

     

    Likes to help people

    This one is a bit of a no-brainer. If you like seeing people fail, you’re in the wrong game. A big driver for recruiters is that placing candidates will generally mean fatter pay cheques but at the heart and soul of being a great recruiter is that you genuinely enjoy helping people and seeing them succeed and flourish. This goes for both your clients and candidates. Great recruiters will work hard for a candidate because they believe in that person, not just because of the financial rewards. The reward is the outcome, especially when you see someone succeed in a role in the long term.

     

    Persistent and optimistic

    Candidates will accept counter-offers and cancel client interviews at the last minute, and clients will reject candidates based on little to no rational reasoning. This is all part and parcel of being an agency recruiter. There are ways to minimalise these risks, but ultimately, they will always exist. Great recruiters are able to understand setbacks are a part of the process, forget about them quickly and move on. Great recruiters may get a few knocks, but they look for the positive in each situation and always focus on retaining relationships even if you don’t get an outcome from that individual or that company. The optimist says that ‘just because it didn’t happen this time round doesn’t mean it won’t happen next time’.

    Are you looking to hire for your Sales or Marketing teams, or are thinking about a new challenge? Maybe you are just looking for some information and insights. If so, give Pulse a call at 02 9387 7005 or e-mail admin@pulserecruitment.com.au.

    FROM OUR PULSE NEWS, EMPLOYER AND JOB SEEKER HUBS

    Featured Articles

    The Most In-Demand Tech Sales Skills for 2026

    The tech sales landscape of 2026 is unrecognizable compared to the “growth at all costs” era of the early 2020s. We have entered the age of Sophisticated Realism. Buyers are more informed, more risk-averse, and more shielded by technology than ever before. In response, the role of the salesperson has undergone a fundamental mutation. In…

    Remote vs. Hybrid: What Australia’s Best Sales Reps are Demanding Now

    The Australian employment landscape has undergone a permanent transformation. For sales organizations, particularly those in the high growth sectors of technology, fintech, and cybersecurity, the traditional office based model is no longer the standard. It is a relic of a previous era. As we navigate the current market, a critical question faces every sales leader…

    Why B2B Sales is a Team Sport in 2026

    For decades, the “Lone Wolf” was the celebrated archetype of the sales world. This was the Account Executive (AE) who worked in a vacuum, kept their secrets close to their chest, and emerged from the shadows only to ring the bell after closing a massive deal. They were the “closers,” the individual heroes whose grit…

    The 2026 GTM Playbook: EQ, Shadow Pipelines, & Talent Gaps

    In the Go-To-Market (GTM) landscape of 2026, the noise is deafening. We were promised that AI would automate our way to infinite scale, but instead, it has created a “trust deficit.” Buyers are shielded by AI gatekeepers, their inboxes are flooded with “hyper-personalized” (yet soulless) outreach, and the old playbooks are being shredded in real-time….

    7 Red Flags to Look for During Your Tech Sales Interview

    The tech sales landscape is a high-octane world of “disruptive” SaaS products, uncapped commissions, and the promise of rapid career progression. On paper, every startup looks like the next unicorn. However, beneath the surface of free kombucha and ergonomic desks, many sales organizations are struggling with toxic cultures, unattainable quotas, and “burn and churn” philosophies…

    Why “Job Hopping” in Sales Might Be Killing Your Long-Term Earnings

    In the modern sales landscape, there is a pervasive belief that the only way to get a significant “raise” is to change companies. The logic seems sound on the surface: jump to a new startup, grab a 20% increase in base salary, vest a few more options, and repeat the cycle every 18 months. Recruiters…

    Culture vs. Quota: Why Top Billers Leave (and How to Make Them Stay)

    In the high-stakes world of professional recruitment and enterprise sales, there is a prevailing myth that “money heals all wounds.” Leadership often believes that as long as the commission checks are fat and the leaderboard is glowing, the “Top Billers”—the 5% who carry 50% of the revenue—are happy. But then, the unthinkable happens. Your star…

    Cold Calling Scripts for Tech Sales Success

    Cold calling remains one of the most debated yet powerful strategies in tech sales. Many sales professionals assume it is outdated, especially with the rise of email marketing, social selling, and AI-driven outreach. However, the reality is different. Cold calling continues to deliver strong results when executed with the right strategy, messaging, and mindset. In…

    Hidden Job Market in Tech Sales: How to Find Unadvertised Roles

    While you’re scrolling through job boards competing with hundreds of applicants for posted positions, an entire ecosystem of unadvertised tech sales roles exists that most candidates never discover. Research shows 70-80% of jobs are filled through networking and referrals before they’re ever publicly advertised. This hidden job market represents your best opportunity to find exceptional…

    How to Attract Sales Reps Who Aren’t Looking

    The best sales talent isn’t browsing job boards—they’re crushing quota at your competitors. These passive candidates represent 70% of the workforce but account for less than 30% of applicants. If you’re only recruiting from active job seekers, you’re fishing in a small pond while ignoring an ocean of high-performing sales professionals. Passive candidate recruitment requires…

    POWERED BY