Skip to content

Employers Hub | How to give your sales staff constructive criticism

Jun 7, 2017

Tarlia Smedley

Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    Many managers can be hesitant to provide their employees with feedback mainly because it is confronting, but also because images of emotional breakdowns and temper tantrums come to mind. This is where constructive feedback comes to the rescue. If implemented effectively, you can reduce the drama, and instead have an insightful conversation that leads to improved performance. This can be not only about their performance but possible improvement strategies.

    How? Here are a few tips our Director, Daniel Hale, suggests.

     

    1 – Identify the problem behaviour and give examples:

    A bad run in a sales team is detrimental. Not only because there are no numbers on the board, but it can also reduce team morale. This is where being able to spot the specific issues affecting this issue is vital. In pinpointing the problem, (whether it is objection handling or closing), you will be able to provide accurate feedback to discuss with your rep. Dan loves to say, “Lets catch up to discuss your progress”. This allows for a friendly opening to the conversation regarding their performance and removes the possibility of them walking into the chat with negative preconceptions. You need to also give specific examples of this and what could have been said/done differently and what the outcome will be if a change is made.

     

    2 – Nip it in the bud early:

    The market is competitive and it is too risky to allow for an underperforming sales rep. Dan suggests that having facts and statistical evidence can really drive your point home.  According to the TAS Group[i] 67% of sales professionals do not attain individual quotas. This can be damaging to the overall output of the sales team and in generating revenue for the company. It’s important to act quickly and decisively before the issue snowballs.

     

    3 – Employee input:

    This is one of the most vital aspects of a successful outcome. Your sales rep is only human (surprise)! So the reason for the dip in their performance may be for personal reasons. By bringing these to the table it enables your sales rep to accept the issue, which is vital in ensuring a change in behaviour. Not to mention that understanding the reasons for their difficulties, can help with finding a solution.

     

    4 – Develop goals:

    As a manager, your aim is to help grow your sales rep’s performance. By working together to find a goal, they are more likely to implement this new approach. This is with an aim to increase conversions, so it could even be as simple as doubling the amount of time spent on lead gen.

     

    5 – Monitor their performance:

    The last step is two-fold. Firstly by sending an email right after the catch-up, will reinforce everything you discussed and have the goals clearly stated. Secondly, set a follow-up meeting. It is preferable to do this a week or two after to check-in to see how they are going with applying the strategies. It will be a lot easier to see the benefits and results if you regularly track their output.

    Overall, Dan suggests not chastising your sales rep, as that will break their confidence. The goal is to cater to their personal development by talking about the future, and strategies to better the situation. Typically the buck stops with the manager.

    So why not implement these easy tips to ensure for a high-performing sales team?

    [i] Ye. L 2015, “10 Surprising stats about sales rep performance”, Hubspot, viewed https://blog.hubspot.com/sales/surprising-stats-about-sales-rep-performance-slideshare#sm.00000y9faaczujey411fbcaquow5h

     

    SEEKING INDUSTRY-LEADING TALENT?

    Leverage Pulse Recruitment’s expertise in IT, sales, and marketing to secure elite professionals in Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane, the wider Asia-Pacific and United States regions. Experience the advantage by connecting with us!

    FROM OUR PULSE NEWS, EMPLOYER AND JOB SEEKER HUBS

    Featured Articles

    GTM Tech Sales Hiring Forecast: What to Expect in Late 2026

    Every quarter, GTM leaders across ANZ ask some version of the same question: are we building the right team for what’s coming, or the team that made sense eighteen months ago? Heading into the back half of 2026, the honest answer for most companies is the latter. Team structures built during the growth-at-all-costs years are…
    How to Handle Objections Without Sounding Scripted

    Most objection-handling training teaches reps a set of pre-written responses to the most common pushback: price, timing, “we’re happy with our current vendor,” “I need to check with my team.” The problem isn’t that these responses are wrong, it’s that buyers can tell when they’re hearing a rehearsed line rather than a genuine response to…
    How AI Is Actually Changing the Sales Cycle

    Every sales conference session, every vendor pitch, and a fair share of LinkedIn posts over the past two years have made some version of the claim that AI is transforming sales. Most of these claims are either significantly overstated or so vague they’re impossible to actually evaluate. The real picture is more specific and, in…
    Sales Forecasting: Why Most Forecasts Are Wrong

    Forecast accuracy is one of the most consistently poor metrics across tech sales organisations, and it’s rarely because the underlying methodology is complicated. Most CRM forecasting tools can handle weighted pipeline, stage-based probability, and historical trend analysis without much difficulty. The problem almost never sits with the tooling. It sits with the inputs, the incentives…
    Why Discovery Calls Are Getting Shorter, and What That Means for Reps

    Five years ago, a standard enterprise discovery call ran forty-five minutes to an hour. Today, plenty of buyers across ANZ are pushing back on anything longer than twenty, and some are declining a discovery call altogether in favour of a written brief or a short async video. This shift has crept up on a lot…
    How AI Has Changed Selling: What Top Sales Reps Do Differently

    Ask a candidate in a sales interview whether they use AI and almost everyone says yes. That answer tells a hiring manager nothing. Every rep has ChatGPT open in a browser tab. Every rep has tried a call recording tool that summarises next steps. Using AI is no longer a differentiator. It’s table stakes. What…
    GTM Tech Sales Hiring Forecast: What to Expect Through Late 2026

    GTM hiring is not collapsing. It is sorting itself into two very different markets, and most people are still planning as if only one of them exists. Overall GTM job postings across US digital native companies fell 15% in Q1 2026 compared to the same period last year, and that pullback continued into April. At…
    How to Write Cold Emails That Get Responses

    Most cold emails fail before the reader gets to the second sentence. Not because the product is weak. Not because the timing is wrong. They fail because the email was written to explain the sender’s company instead of starting a conversation with the reader. Open almost any inbox and the pattern repeats itself. A paragraph…
    How to Scale a GTM Sales Team: A Complete Guide to Building a High-Performing Revenue Engine

    Every high-growth company reaches a point where its early sales strategy stops working. In the beginning, founders often handle sales themselves. They build relationships, close the first customers, and refine the product based on direct customer feedback. This founder-led approach is essential for achieving product-market fit, but it isn’t designed to scale. As demand grows,…
    How to Optimize Your Sales GTM Funnel

    Every GTM team has a funnel. Very few teams actually know where theirs is leaking. Leadership looks at top of funnel volume and bottom of funnel revenue, sees a gap between the two, and calls it conversion rate. That number tells you almost nothing about what to actually fix. Optimizing a GTM funnel is not…

    Visit our blog page

    POWERED BY